POST 32 THOUGHTS ON GOVERNMENT

5 min.

Providential Orchestration and the American Founding

Blueprint for a Balanced Republic

John Adams was a man of extraordinary insights. In a visionary assessment he wrote, “Soon after the Reformation, a few people came over into this New World for conscience sake. Perhaps this apparently trivial incident may transfer the great seat of empire to America…” He was also convinced that reconciliation was impossible; that the crisis with England would never be settled peaceably.

Adams saw the moment as providential — a rare opportunity for mankind to choose a new form of government based on reason, virtue, and the rights of man. Upon his return to Philadelphia in February 1776, he drew up a list of what he was determined to see accomplished. Independence was the only chance at American liberty, and he was determined that the great step be taken. The only question was when to make the move. Across the top of a page in his diary, he titled his work A Declaration of Independency.

With the delegates equally divided among opposition, caution, and independence, the Continental Congress was strained and the mood of Philadelphia contentious. When word arrived that Parliament had denounced as traitors all Americans who did not make an unconditional submission to British rule, the punishment, as every delegate knew, would be death by hanging. Having been advised early on by Dr. Benjamin Rush that they were perceived as “too zealous” and that they must defer to the “very proud” Virginians, who felt they had the right to lead, the New Englanders bided their time while holding firm for independence.

There were times on the debate floor when the arguments reached fever pitch. The “cool faction,” driven by pacifist Quakerism, continued to support peaceful methods for resolving the crisis. In the words of George Washington, these were those “still feeding themselves upon the dainty food of reconciliation.” In the heat of the moment this group, led by John Dickinson, even threatened to break off from the others and “carry on the opposition by ourselves in our own way.”

As to his feelings regarding half measures, Adams wrote to General Horatio Gates: “The middle way is no way at all. If we finally fail in this great and glorious contest, it will be by bewildering ourselves in groping for the middle way.”

What neither Dickinson nor Adams nor anyone could have anticipated was the stunning effect of Common Sense…a call to arms, an unabashed argument for war, and a call for American independence. “Everything that is right or reasonable pleads for separation,” wrote Thomas Paine. Though agreeing with Paine that the time was ripe for revolution Adams saw no quick victory, nor did he concur with what he labeled as Paine’s “feeble” understanding of the kind of government (a unicameral legislature) that should be established once independence was achieved.

Euphoric that he stood at the gateway to a new epoch of history and that he was an active agent in that new age, Adams expressed his sentiments in Thoughts on Government: “It has been the will of Heaven that we should be thrown into existence at a period when the greatest philosophers and lawgivers of antiquity would have wished to live… How few of the human race have ever had an opportunity of choosing a system of government for themselves and their children?” Acknowledging a Higher Power, he was looking beyond independence and the outcome of the war.

“The happiness of the people was the purpose of government,” Adams wrote, “and therefore that form of government was best which produced the greatest amount of happiness for the largest number. And since all sober inquirers after truth agreed that happiness derived from virtue, that form of government with virtue as its foundation was more likely than any other to promote the general happiness.

“The greatest minds agreed,” Adams continued, “that all good government was republican, and the true idea of a republic was ‘an empire of laws and not of men.’ A government with a single legislative body would never do. Essential to the stability of government and to an able and impartial administration of justice, was separation of judicial power from both the legislative and executive.” Urging the widest possible support for education, he added: “Laws for the liberal education of youth are extremely wise and useful.”

At the end of his Thoughts Adams expressed the wonder shared by his colleagues at the opportunity to substantially contribute to the future happiness of the human race. Honored to fulfill their roles, the Founders accepted that there was a discernable order in the universe that should govern in human affairs as it governs the world of nature. They accepted that the source of that order was God, or a Higher Power. In a time of collective humility, and with a firm reliance on the protection of Divine Providence, they were in accord that since a sparrow could not fall without his notice it was improbable that a great nation could rise without his aid.

John Adams’ ideas spread quickly. Upon request, he gave a copy of “Thoughts” to George Wythe, America’s first law professor, dean of the Virginia bar, and Thomas Jefferson’s patron. In the months that followed, driven by expression of popular will, the power of the ardent revolutionaries increased as the conservative and moderate elements lost credibility through their dogged opposition to independence.

In the development of his own views, Thomas Jefferson had been more cautious than Adams, due in major part to Virginia’s dependence on English creditors and the lure of aristocratic life. Now, however, upon his arrival in Philadelphia, his commitment was no less than Adams’ own. In their devotion to the common cause of America, both men joined with others who craved independence and viewed themselves as participants at a crucial juncture of history.

On June 7, in Independence Hall, Richard Henry Lee, following three days of fierce debate, introduced the process that would turn the world upside down: “Resolved: That these United Colonies are, and of right ought to be, free and independent States.”

Jefferson was the protege, Adams the mentor. On June 10, the Committee of Five, consisting of Jefferson, Adams, Roger Sherman, Robert Livingston, and Benjamin Franklin, was appointed to prepare a declaration of independence. Valuing Jefferson’s literary talents and recognizing the political advantage in having the declaration written by a Virginian, Adams considered Jefferson the best choice for the task.

website: americasgranddesign.com

blog: http://www.americasgrand.design